I still wouldn't give it to Mark Buehrle.
That is a tough call though, especially when you look at the 4 other pitchers that are racking in very similar numbers as of right now.
But lets pretend for a minute that the season ended today, AND that Buehrle did not just throw the 18th perfect game in MLB history yesterday. Who would be the top 5 candidates?
Well, in the Mind of Shinny, here are my picks (in no particular order):
-Roy Halliday
-Felix Hernandez
-Zack Greinke
-Josh Beckett
-Mark Buehrle
The Cy Young is for the BEST pitcher in baseball. To be the best pitcher in baseball you have to have the best command, the best pitches, the best stamina, and a lot of luck that doesn't get put into numbers. Most of the time it translates into helping your team win, but not all the time. And that's what the MVP award is for anyway.
Out of all of my top 5, Greinke is the only pitcher not in the 11-win club, and the only one in the group to mass 5 losses. But he does have more innings pitched than Halliday AND Beckett, along with the best ERA among the 5. But ERA and innings pitched doesn't quite convince me he deserves it. Or does he...
Keep in mind, we're
JUST talking about the AL. Categorically, here's who is top dog:
Best command: Halliday, by a long shot.
His 17 walks are the fewest among my group of pitchers, and when you look at his AB statistics, he walks the fewest amount of batters after falling behind 2-0. The most amount of walks he has given up is when he gets into a full count. Better yet, when he gets ahead 0-2, he has only walked 2 (and just 19 hits allowed in that situation).
Best Stamina: Greinke
He has 5 complete games, 1 more than Halliday, and his 134.1 innings pitched rank top 5 among starters. He also throws about 105 pitches per start. He's the guy I want on the hill if my team is in the middle of a losing streak or if my bullpen is taxed. No longer the headcase he was from last year, and he's on pace to hit 19 wins.
Best "stuff:" Beckett and Hernandez
I'm looking at the Hits and Strikeouts categories for this one, because you will see everything in each start they put up. They will either take care of business themselves with a little help from his defense on a good day, or use their defense a lot and scatter a few hits on a bad day. Beckett and Hernandez both have identical records at 11-3, but Hernandez leads Beckett in strikeouts with 137. Both guys are hovering around 111-117 hits allowed so far this season, and have pitched a lot of innings.
Most efficient: Buehrle
He usually doesn't go above 100 pitches per start, and works quickly and attacks the strike zone. If you saw the perfect game yesterday, you know what I'm talking about. But his perfect game is just a microcosm of what he's been doing all this season (usually). He has only lost twice in a row once, and was unbeaten until the middle of may because of his efficiency.
So I have to pick a winner, but quickly, I want to snub some guys too.
Tim Wakefield and Edwin Jackson.
Wake would be my pick for Red Sox MVP because of how he goes out and plays "stopper" in mostly every start. Not to mention, he only has 3 no-decisions this season, putting together 9 consecutive starts with a decision between May 2nd and June 16th. But he still walks too many (yes he's a Knuckleballer), and while he does well with runners on base, he gets in trouble by allowing too many 2-out hits, home runs, and RBIs. So am I saying that Wakefield will never win the Cy Young because he's a Knuckleballer? No. But that still doesn't give him an excuse when comparing him among the other great pitchers in the game right now either.
And I just don't like Edwin Jackson. His command sucks (40 walks), and he's a streaky pitcher. But as of now he does have a lot going for him, with a 2.52 ERA, 99 hits, and 129 IP, just below Beckett. He's on pace to reach 180 strikeouts, so his 7-5 record really doesn't do justice to how his season's going. But I just don't like him.
So my "1st Half Shinny's Mind AL Cy Young Winner" is....
HALLIDAY. With Beckett and Greinke in a CLOSE 2nd.
It seems like every time Halliday steps on the hill, it's a domination or a close game with few runs scored. This dude is electric, no way around it. It seems like the popular choice right now, but trust me, when you look at his numbers it's the obvious choice too.